Key Takeaways
Counselors focus on specific issues with solution-oriented support; therapists apply psychotherapy to address ongoing patterns; and psychologists use advanced diagnostics and testing to treat complex mental health disorders.
Education and experience requirements for counselors and therapists typically take 7-9 years, while requirements for psychologists take 10-13 years.
To choose the right professional pathway, consider how long you want to spend in school, the scope of practice you're interested in, and your anticipated return on investment (cost of education vs. earnings).
Counseling, therapy, and psychology are mental health service fields that focus on treating mental, emotional, and behavioral health conditions. However, it's important to understand how these fields differ — especially as you ponder which path to pursue in your education and career. Use this guide to gain insights into these fields' differentiating characteristics.
Popular Online Psychology Master's Programs
Learn about start dates, transferring credits, availability of financial aid, and more by contacting the universities below.
Counseling, Therapy, or Psychology? Key Similarities and Differences
Counselors, therapists, and psychologists all require graduate degrees and supervised clinical training. However, these practitioners must meet unique education and licensing requirements, and their scopes of professional practice also differ.
Similarities
All three careers require state-level licensure, though specific requirements vary by state. They also share the common characteristic of supporting mental health and well-being through applied psychology.
As a student, you do not necessarily require a specific undergraduate degree to enter a graduate program in any of the three fields.
Differences
Counselors: Counselors generally help clients deal with specific issues affecting their mental well-being. While counselors sometimes use psychotherapy, they are generally more likely to offer solution-focused support.
Therapists: Therapists and counselors have similar roles, though therapists often favor psychotherapy when working with clients.
Psychologists: Licensed psychologists require either a Psy.D. or a Ph.D. in psychology, giving them a deeper, more advanced knowledge base. In professional practice, they often draw on a broader toolset to address complex mental health challenges.
Educational Requirements for Counselors, Therapists, and Psychologists
In most cases, each of the three career paths requires a graduate degree, including an internship or practicum. You can typically enter any of the three fields with any undergraduate major that includes social sciences coursework. Graduate-level programs teach the specific techniques and strategies used by professional practitioners.
Counselors
Graduate counseling programs study human development, counseling techniques, and how to deliver effective, culturally responsive counseling to groups and individuals.
To earn a counseling license, you usually need at least a master's degree. However, some specializations — such as substance use disorder counseling — require less education in some states but have a more limited scope of practice.
Education timeline: Six years
Minimum degree required: Master's degree in counseling, psychology, or social work
Internship requirements: These vary by specialty, but usually cover 100-200 hours of observation and 600-700 hours of active internship work under the supervision of a licensed counselor.
Therapists
Master's programs in therapy cover human psychological development, mental health diagnostics, and psychotherapy techniques and strategies. Most states also require you to work under a licensed therapist before you can practice independently.
Education timeline: Six years
Minimum degree required: Master's degree in a therapy specialization, social work, or psychology
Internship requirements: Graduate programs usually require 100 or more observation hours and at least 600 internship hours.
Psychologists
Psychologists require a doctorate in psychology to become licensed. States usually accept either an applied Psy.D. doctorate or a research-focused Ph.D. These advanced educational requirements may impact your psychologist vs. therapist vs. counselor career decision: Becoming a licensed psychologist is an intensive undertaking.
Education timeline: 9-11 years
Minimum degree required: Ph.D. or Psy.D. in psychology
Internship requirements: States require 1,500-6,000 hours of clinical fieldwork under the supervision of a licensed psychologist.
Comparing Licensing Requirements for Mental Health Professionals
Licensing requirements vary by state, specialty, and job function. Some states also use different licensing standards for substance use counseling than general mental health counseling and similar careers in psychology.
Supervised experience and examination requirements also apply to the licensing process in all three professional tracks, as described below:
Counselors
To obtain a counseling license, you must pass either the National Counselor Examination (NCE) or the National Clinical Mental Health Counseling Examination (NCMHCE). The NCE uses a multiple-choice format, while the NCMHCE consists of 10 counseling simulations.
Supervised experience: 1-3 years
Total time to become licensed: 7-9 years
To learn more: Consult resources from the National Board for Certified Counselors or the American Counseling Association.
Therapists
The exam you must pass to earn your therapist license depends on your state and specialization. Requirements commonly include the NCE and the Marital and Family Therapy National Examination (MFT), which is administered by the Association of Marital and Family Therapy Review Board.
Supervised experience: 1-3 years
Total time to become licensed: 7-9 years
To learn more: Consult the Association of Marital and Family Therapy Regulatory Boards or the Association of Social Work Boards.
Psychologists
Most states use the Examination for Professional Practice in Psychology (EPPP) as the default licensing examination. Passing grades vary by state, but EPPP test-takers generally need a 70% score. Many states also require a separate jurisprudence examination.
Supervised experience: 1-2 years
Total time to become licensed: 10-13 years
To learn more: Visit the American Psychological Association.
Practice Differences for Counselors, Therapists, and Psychologists
Counselors, therapists, and psychologists differ significantly in their scopes of practice. The descriptions below explore divergences in counseling vs. therapy vs. clinical or counseling psychology:
Counselors
Counselors provide advice and psychological counseling to clients, often to address a specific issue such as dealing with grief or making career decisions. They help the client understand their problem and the best way to solve it, using short-term or long-term treatment models as required by the client's situation.
Common specializations: Addiction and substance use, career, marriage and family, mental health, rehabilitation
Annual salary range: $51,820-$76,960 (BLS, May 2025)
Projected job growth (2024-2034): +4% (school and career counselors), +17% (substance abuse, behavioral disorder, and mental health counselors) (BLS, May 2024)
Therapists
Therapists are similar to counselors, but they typically apply psychotherapy to address patterns or ongoing problems rather than a single, specific issue. They help clients identify and remedy the underlying psychological issues driving specific mental or behavioral health concerns.
Common specializations: Art, depression, marriage and family, mindfulness, PTSD/trauma
Annual salary range: $76,960-$101,280 (BLS, May 2025)
Projected job growth (2024-2034): +13% (BLS, May 2024)
Psychologists
State regulations vary but in general, psychologists and psychiatrists can perform official psychological testing and diagnoses across the full spectrum of psychological disorders. Clinical psychologists specialize in diagnosing and treating long-term mental health conditions, while counseling psychologists focus on counseling specifically.
Common specializations: Child, clinical, cognitive-behavioral, counseling, forensic, health
Annual salary range: $99,160-$170,230 (BLS, May 2025)
Projected job growth (2024-2034): +6% (BLS, May 2024)
Counselor, Therapist, or Psychologist: Which One Is Right for Me?
Comparing counseling vs. therapy vs. clinical counseling vs. clinical psychology can be difficult and confusing, especially at an early stage. To help guide you during your search for educational programs, start by answering the following questions:
How much time are you willing to spend in school?
Does one or more of these career paths connect with the specific way you would like to help clients?
What are your financial goals?
Also, consider the unique advantages and drawbacks associated with each of these three careers in psychology:
Counseling
Advantages
Counselors are in high demand nationwide with a 17% projected job growth rate from 2024-2034 — much higher than the average 3% job growth for all occupations.
You can enter this field with a master's degree and become licensed, then add a doctorate later to qualify as a psychologist.
Disadvantages
Many fields with equivalent educational requirements pay considerably more.
Therapy
Advantages
Therapists work across a wide variety of specializations and settings.
Many therapists enjoy the way their work makes a meaningful difference in their clients' lives.
Disadvantages
Therapy can be frustrating for both practitioners and clients who prefer or expect rapid results.
Psychology
Advantages
Psychologists tend to earn more money than both counselors and therapists.
A study published in 2019 found that 93% of U.S. psychologists were satisfied with their jobs.
Disadvantages
The long path to psychologist licensure involves intensive commitments of time, effort, and money.
Burnout can occur: A 2023 study found that 36% of surveyed psychologists felt overworked.
Careers in Psychology, Counseling, and Therapy
There are common specialties among mental health professionals. For example, counselors, therapists, psychologists, and psychiatrists can work with people dealing with substance use disorders, however, their job titles and scope of practice differ.
Careers in Counseling
Substance Use Counselor: Substance use counselors provide advice and support in helping clients with substance use disorders. These professionals are in strong demand in many communities, especially due to the ongoing opioid crisis. Substance use counselors work directly with clients and may also collaborate with the client's family and friends.
Licensed Mental Health Counselor: Licensed mental health counselors work with clients seeking to address a specific mental health issue. They may help clients process a traumatic event or address a chronic mental health condition. Some mental health counselors specialize in specific issues, such as phobias, grief and loss, or anxiety.
Behavioral Counselor: Behavioral counselors help clients address specific behaviors, such as addiction, impulsive behavior, or behaviors associated with autism spectrum disorders. They may help clients identify behavioral triggers or how to substitute a healthier behavior for a maladaptive one.
Careers in Therapy
Marriage and Family Therapist: These specialists help couples or families understand patterns of dysfunction or conflict and how to address them. They also help clients identify and come to terms with underlying issues impacting their relationship or family dynamics.
Licensed Clinical Social Worker:Licensed clinical social workers (LCSWs) are authorized to provide therapy to social work clients. Many work for government agencies or nonprofits, but an LCSW can also operate as an independent practitioner.
School Counselor: School counselors work in schools at all levels to address issues such as bullying, interpersonal skills, and educational and career choices. In K-12 environments, they typically work with students, teachers, and parents or guardians.
Careers in Psychology
Clinical Psychology: Clinical psychologists diagnose and treat complex or severe mental health conditions. However, with limited exceptions, they cannot prescribe medication. In comparing counseling vs. clinical psychology, note that clinical psychologists tend to focus more on pathologies and complex mental health conditions.
Counseling Psychology: Counseling psychologists use practitioner-led counseling techniques to help clients understand and address issues affecting their psychological wellness. These professionals work in various settings, including private practices, hospitals, healthcare facilities, and schools.
Forensic Psychology: Forensic psychologists work at the intersection of law, criminal justice, and psychology. They perform mental wellness assessments for legal purposes, consult on jury psychology and analysis, and carry out psychology-oriented studies of crime and criminality.
Meet a Psychologist
Dr. Jaime Zuckerman is a Philadelphia-based clinical psychologist in private practice, specializing in adults with anxiety, depression, and those adjusting to medical illnesses. Dr. Zuckerman received her undergraduate degree from Ohio State University and her doctorate in clinical psychology from La Salle University. She completed her internship and postdoctoral fellowship at LIJ Medical Center in New York. After returning to Pennsylvania, she took a position as head psychologist at the Coatesville VA Medical Center for the acute medical, nursing, and hospice units.
She was also actively involved in an internship training program. In 2009, Dr. Zuckerman accepted the position as director of psychology at The Center for Neuroscience in Media, Pennsylvania, where she remained for several years until entering private practice full time. In addition to her practice, Dr. Zuckerman offers seminars and support groups for the Epilepsy Foundation of Eastern Pennsylvania and frequently presents at their conferences.
What drew you to a career as a psychologist?
Answer – First, I had always been interested in how the body worked. Even as a young child, I was always fascinated with the pictures in my father's medical textbooks. Eventually, when I got to high school, I took an intro to psychology course as an elective and began to take a real interest in the brain and its role in emotions, cognition, and behaviors.
I was fascinated by the fact that electrical impulses in our heads were solely responsible for every action, every thought, and every decision we made. I also became very interested in behaviorism and how modifying even the smallest of reinforcement schedules could drastically alter behavior. I loved the idea that there was a way to explain and modify what seemed like intangible variables, such as emotions and thoughts.
I also felt an innate obligation to help others. For as long as I can remember, I have held the belief that if you are in a position to help others, you do so. And what better way to combine my two interests of brain-based behavior and helping others than to become a clinical psychologist?
Why did you choose this path over similar care roles, such as a counselor or therapist?
Answer – I chose to earn a doctorate in clinical psychology because I wanted the flexibility to work across different domains within the field. It enabled me to teach, see patients and work in various types of institutions. Furthermore, I wanted to develop a more specialized approach to the empirically supported treatment of adults, specifically in cognitive behavior therapy and acceptance and commitment therapy.
I was very interested in the extended clinical training of the two-year practicums, the year-long pre-doctoral internship, and the year-long postdoc experiences. In addition to the clinical experience offered by a doctoral program, I wanted to take part in research opportunities. It was important to me that I become an educated consumer of empirical research in the field, and I contributed to it, too.
What are some of your most significant day-to-day challenges?
Answer – First, social media has inevitably affected the practice of psychology. In fact, and this is especially true for my millennial patients, social media is an integral part of their interpersonal experiences. To understand their experiences, I must remain aware of the ever-changing social media landscape. Second, social media has drastically changed the way psychologists market themselves.
Whether it's a practice's website or an informational Instagram page, psychologists' presence on social media has become somewhat commonplace. While I do believe that such a platform can be extremely beneficial, it remains a grey area. Currently, there are no hard rules about social media presence other than not engaging with your patients on these platforms. Finding that healthy and appropriate balance is something that I have found to be a day-to-day challenge.
Juggling different roles also presents a challenge. In addition to working as a clinical psychologist, I am also a mother of three little children, all under the age of seven. Coordinating schedules, homework, doctor appointments, playdates, and carpools keeps my head swimming—and that is before I add in seeing patients. I sometimes struggle with the constant switching of hats from psychologist to mom, but with time management strategies and leaving room for self-care and a lot of support, it can be truly rewarding.
What do you find most rewarding about a career as a psychologist?
Answer – By far, the most rewarding thing about my career as a psychologist is seeing my patients improve. There is nothing better than a patient who once had crippling social anxiety beginning dating, or a person with severe depression re-enrolling in school and finishing their semester with a 4.0. Seeing a patient with low self-esteem and toxic relational patterns finally understand and change their behaviors is such a satisfying thing to observe. Also, it is extremely gratifying when patients who have been in therapy with me for some time permanently incorporate our therapeutic language into their everyday problem-solving.
What advice would you give prospective students considering pursuing a career as a psychologist?
Answer – First, make sure you thoroughly research the programs that interest you. Are they APA-accredited? Ask current and former students about their experiences and opinions. This will give you a better feel for the culture of the program itself. Ask about available practicum sites. Most importantly, ask about their pre-doctoral internship match rates. Do more than just read their online material.
Second, while you don't necessarily need to know the nuances of your specialty at this point in your journey, it may be helpful to narrow down a few criteria. For example, do you want to steer more towards academia, clinical application, or both? There is a common misconception that all Psy.D. programs are purely clinical and that Ph.D. programs are solely research. This is not always the case.
My Psy.D. program included a significant amount of required research. Make sure to narrow down the general population you wish to work with (e.g., children vs. adults) as this can help to determine the program you choose.
Know that the next 5-7 years are a major commitment. I watched many of my friends take lucrative jobs, get married, and have children while I was still studying in graduate school. I would be lying if I didn't say I felt like I had put my life on hold. But, in the end, I realized I had not. It's just that my path to get where I wanted to be was a bit longer than theirs, and there is nothing wrong with that. It is a long journey, but a rewarding one in the end. In the words of my mentor, "If it were easy, everyone would do it."
Frequently Asked Questions About Differences Between Psychology, Counseling, and Therapy
Counselors generally offer solution-focused support for a single mental health, psychological, or behavioral issue. Therapists help clients address single issues or patterns of behavior, generally with psychotherapy. Psychologists tend to deal with more complex and serious mental health issues using a complete spectrum of diagnostic and treatment techniques.
